Idiot ic research





Saturday, 18 May 2013

LSE 'On Beauty' - Aesthetics lecture May 2013

Very rough notes from a philosophy lecture this week - will tidy up at some point

Historically Art was categorised as something 'interesting' as opposed to in a sepearate category from 'interesting'.

Beauty = the aesthetic category. Beautiful less significant than interesting.

18th Century the word beauty was created - even though it was an ancient concept.

Beauty went from poets to philosophers when Pythagoras discovered the mathematical ratio's corresponding to octaves in music. suddenly art could be explained - hidden order, symmetry. (golden section)

Philosophical ideas that reflect cultural ideas and taste RESONATE. 

Plato and Aristotle convinced by the idea that beauty can be defined in terms of numbers.

Aristotle thought that the male body was more beautiful as better articulated - the greeks liked articulation, you can see by their urns.

Challenges - 

Socrates - beauty is functionality

Plotinus - simple qualities, the gold star shines beautifully

Nietzsche - ich weiss nicht

Kant

Cannot be defined....YET purely attrinbutable to form. So leads to a fallacy - numbers cannot define all form?

Well - enjoyment of beauty is a playful version of absorbing form e.e a cat playing with newspaper in place of mice. 'Free play' ('moral' freedom?)

'a rule' together with 'freedom' created a tension.

Certain rules can make it more likely but no rule. The notion plus absence of rules. (see antinomy of taste). 

Subective matter? But we have an urge to convince other that there is something objective?

Artists engage in free play when they make art.

When in this state the will produce something beautiful.

(distinction between art and craft)

Artsits transmits something that cannot be conveyed any other way. Antiquity - art can be trained (cobbler, plato)

Art almost passive in fact - artist is a medium for message transmission?

 - Represent nature whilst being distinct from it. Beauty in nature THEN beauty in art?

OR 

- We find what is beautiful in nature because of our encounters with art.

Is one dependent on or derivative from the other?

Are they sufficiently different?

((What is nature? Who created that?!))

The way we look at (aesthetic experience/appreciation) individual objects in nature vs. scenes in comparison with art e.g. a frame around a daisy.

e.g. Claude painting interiors then aristocrats wanting their interiors like the paintings.

Distinction between the beautiful - Pleasing form, and the sublime - less delightful/pleasing maybee awe and fear e..g mountains bigger than us, vast and powerful, but we are safe so can enjoy the frisson!

'Safety valve to release the pressure of neo-classicism' Sublime is

Awareness of our ability to observe finite symbols of the infinite. Transcend nature with out imagination. Sublimity within ourselves. OUR power.

Tolstoy - pierre sees star as representation of his own feeling. Remarkably similar to the essence of shoepenhauer.

Kant - ability to absorb beauty rooted in our nature as intellectual 9cognitive) beings (No animals)

Burk - Beauty rooted in sexual. Love and passion. The restrained peaceful love we feel for friends (?). Animals too.

Hogarth - Line of beauty, sinuous path of pursuit, like that a dog takes wehn pursuing a stick. Sense of beauty found in animals as well.

Darwin - The peacocks tails (descent of man)
Sexual selection - didnt evolve to score preditors but to attract pea hen, the females have selected the most beautiful tailed males so they have evolved. How did the females sense of beauty evolve??Why?? Healthy male. Conspicuous consumption. Ornaments are expensive to produce.

Adaptive nature - What looks better? Beauty equated with attractiveness?? Want to be part of, have make part of you. 

Every human trait product of natural/human selection so beauty too?

What is here to say above the empirical scientific explanation?

20th century art moved away from classic beauty to 'say something'. Art making as a form of philosophy. Duchamp urinal beautiful.

apolinere - ugly should be beautiful!

Beauty just pretty so not interesting? No there is room for combination.

xenophanes memoribillia. Socrates - relates beauty and function. e.g. a beautiful javelinthrower vs. beautiful wrestler. Golden shielf not beautiful as not adapted to its function. 

Association of beauty and functionality was strengthened during industrialisation end of 19th Century. Van Gogh - aim simply to be honest before nature (?)

Kant - central function.
distinction between free and dependent beauty function How it does what it should be doing best.

'arousal of an emotion in the mind' poem by saffo '...whatever you love'

Certain properties more difficult to explain (metaphysically), moral, experienced based.
Reduce more complicated to more basic.

Greatest term of aesthetic praise. Interaction of aesthetic and moral value. The agreeable Kant law. 

Why is the enjoyment of beauty given more valuye than other pleasures/senses? Associating beauty with other values e.g. morally good. Promise of happiness?

Mary mothers ' beauty restored'

Subjectivity of beauty, greek poem.

Beauty as pain relief.

Humanity to desire to destroy beauty? Association with pleasure. Ultimate offense to destroy something beautiful sometimes to ourselves. 

Character destroys aesthetic beauty. Beauty linked to Virture Colin McGinn.

'beautiful person' personality is key.